He's coming straight for us! |
The Hit
The source material continues to deliver songs I do not know…
The packaging is enticing - I mean, the possibilities of a name like “Hurricane Smith” - and the title, “Oh, Babe What Would You Say” sounds era-specific, e.g., easy-listening, care-free (self-absorbed?). A little shimmer announces the song, then the horns come in with a swinging, happy melody - so far, so good - and the beat plays at a simple, upbeat finger-snapping clip…and then Hurricane Smith starts singing.
I can handle a wide variety of singing styles: starting from actual barking, passing through atonal yelling, up to voices so nasally that you’d swear it’d take the power of helium to pull them off (and yet the artiste needed none), and onward up to voices of pure velvet that make you want to weep at their beauty. I’ve loved vocals that fell many, many miles short of pitch-perfect, in other words, but they should possess a certain quality that compliments either the music or the project - and I’ve certainly heard worse voices than Hurricane Smith’s. He carries the tune nicely through some of the verses, but he definitely strains to hit notes outside that range and often fails to reach them; something like growling comes and goes. It doesn’t really add anything to what he does, at least not beyond a sort of homely sincerity. The whole thing comes off as a game attempt at karaoke, basically.
It feels like a novelty act, a put-on, maybe some famous person’s musical alter-ego. But it wasn’t.
The Rest of the Story
Norman “Hurricane” Smith had a remarkable career, no question. He was the sound engineer for The Beatles early career, everything up to Rubber Soul. He moved over to producing after that where he had a hand in making Pink Floyd famous, working on their albums The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, A Saucerful of Secrets and Ummagumma. It is very hard, in other words, to be more at the center of mid-to-late-60s English rock than Smith - and that’s before throwing producing credits for the Pretty Things’ S. F. Sorrow, aka, “one of rock’s first concept albums,” onto the pile.
The source material continues to deliver songs I do not know…
The packaging is enticing - I mean, the possibilities of a name like “Hurricane Smith” - and the title, “Oh, Babe What Would You Say” sounds era-specific, e.g., easy-listening, care-free (self-absorbed?). A little shimmer announces the song, then the horns come in with a swinging, happy melody - so far, so good - and the beat plays at a simple, upbeat finger-snapping clip…and then Hurricane Smith starts singing.
I can handle a wide variety of singing styles: starting from actual barking, passing through atonal yelling, up to voices so nasally that you’d swear it’d take the power of helium to pull them off (and yet the artiste needed none), and onward up to voices of pure velvet that make you want to weep at their beauty. I’ve loved vocals that fell many, many miles short of pitch-perfect, in other words, but they should possess a certain quality that compliments either the music or the project - and I’ve certainly heard worse voices than Hurricane Smith’s. He carries the tune nicely through some of the verses, but he definitely strains to hit notes outside that range and often fails to reach them; something like growling comes and goes. It doesn’t really add anything to what he does, at least not beyond a sort of homely sincerity. The whole thing comes off as a game attempt at karaoke, basically.
It feels like a novelty act, a put-on, maybe some famous person’s musical alter-ego. But it wasn’t.
The Rest of the Story
Norman “Hurricane” Smith had a remarkable career, no question. He was the sound engineer for The Beatles early career, everything up to Rubber Soul. He moved over to producing after that where he had a hand in making Pink Floyd famous, working on their albums The Piper at the Gates of Dawn, A Saucerful of Secrets and Ummagumma. It is very hard, in other words, to be more at the center of mid-to-late-60s English rock than Smith - and that’s before throwing producing credits for the Pretty Things’ S. F. Sorrow, aka, “one of rock’s first concept albums,” onto the pile.